Challenging Exile: Japanese Canadians and the Wartime Constitution
Review By Ian G. Baird
October 22, 2026
Challenging Exile: Japanese Canadians and the Wartime Constitution, authored by Eric M. Adams, a law professor at the University of Alberta, and Jordan Stanger-Ross, a history professor at the University of Victoria, is—as the authors describe it—“the story of how more than ten thousand Japanese Canadians came to be threatened with banishment at the close of the Second World War, and the resilience of the people who faced exile” (246). But the book is, in fact, much more than just that. It is also about the almost 4,000 who were eventually exiled in 1946, and the Canadian courts that dealt with questions of citizenship and race in relation to Japanese Canadians during and after the Second World War.
Challenging Exile is a fascinating read, as it weaves together the expertise of its two authors. Adams brings Canadian legal history, and particularly constitutional history, to the project, while Stanger-Ross contributes years of experience conducting research regarding the history of Japanese Canadian dispossession, making for an fruitful collaboration.
The book is divided into 14 chapters, as well as a short epilogue, and a preface to introduce the book written by Audrey Kobayashi, a prominent geographer and Japanese Canadian.
Challenging Exile provides important background information about Japanese Canadians, beginning with Canada and Japan going to war in late 1941, and the subsequent uprooting of the over 22,000 Japanese Canadians from coastal British Columbia, in 1942. They largely went to official internment camps in southeastern BC, so-called “self-supporting communities” outside of the 100-mile “protection area”, across the Rocky Mountains to sugar beet farms in southern Alberta, Saskatchewan or Manitoba, and to prisoner-of-war camps in Ontario.
Crucially, the circumstances of Japanese Canadians were worse than for Japanese Americans. First, the Canadian government sold all the property of Japanese Canadians, something the US government did not do. Second, Japanese Americans were able to return to their homes in early 1945, even before Japan surrendered, but the Canadian government applied the War Measures Act to justify racist objectives designed to manage people of “the Japanese race” in Canada. Law was unjustly applied to keep Japanese Canadians from returning to the coast until the spring of 1949, almost four years after the end of the war. Finally, unlike the US, the Canadian government embarked on a plan to exile as many Japanese Canadians to Japan as possible, and spread the remaining population across Canada.
Challenging Exile is particularly timely, as through addressing the history of legal injustices to uprooted Japanese Canadians, the authors successfully engage with legal topics of great importance today, including those related to citizenship and deportation. The book also clearly demonstrates how racially discriminatory the Canadian government was to Japanese Canadians, and how deeply the racism was embedded in the courts, leading to decisions that tolerated state-sanctioned racism. The timing of the book is also important because it coincides with the historic decision of the BC government, just a few years ago, to grant $100 million to Japanese Canadians in lieu of the grave injustices that BC inflicted on them during and after the Second World War.
Challenging Exile is destined to become a standard text for Asian Studies and Canadian legal scholars, but will also be of interest to many Japanese Canadians who want to make a deep dive into the legal and constitutional issues associated with Japanese Canadians. Crucially, the book demonstrates how the unjust treatment of Japanese Canadians played significantly into reforming Canada’s legal system, including adopting Canada’s first bill of rights.
Publication Information
Eric M. Adams and Jordan Stanger-Ross, Challenging Exile: Japanese Canadians and the Wartime Constitution. University of British Columbia Press, 2025.